Top Real Estate Agents in St. Augustine, FL for 2026

St. Augustine had 444 closed sales on record in the last 12 months. The 25 agents ranked here closed 759 of the sales in St. Augustine over the last three years. The list starts from recorded local sales, recent volume and reviews from clients with a completed transaction. See our editorial policy.

Updated November 2026. Rankings are recomputed daily. How we rank

1

Nancy Pruitt

Olympus Executive Realty Inc, Montverde, FL
No reviews yet
197sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$402Mvolume (12 mo)
$544Kavg. price
2292 recorded sales
2

Charlie Rogers

Dr Horton Realty Inc., St Johns, FL
No reviews yet
199sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$105Mvolume (12 mo)
$311Kavg. price
949 recorded sales
3

Karen Lindsey

Lighthouse Realty Associates, St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
38sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$16Mvolume (12 mo)
$623Kavg. price
50 recorded sales
4

Frank Perez-Andreu

Keller Williams Realty Atlantic Partners (st. Aug), St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
28sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$11Mvolume (12 mo)
$677Kavg. price
33 recorded sales
5

Donald Della Sala

DJ & Lindsey Real Estate, St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
27sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$9.2Mvolume (12 mo)
$457Kavg. price
288 recorded sales
6

Nicholas Linser

One Sothebys International, Palm Coast, FL
No reviews yet
24sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$8.4Mvolume (12 mo)
$519Kavg. price
38 recorded sales
7

Justin Petrucci

Beach State Realty, St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
15sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$8.6Mvolume (12 mo)
$250Kavg. price
73 recorded sales
8

Dawn Humphrey

Keller Williams Realty Atlantic Partners (st. Aug), St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
27sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$2.3Mvolume (12 mo)
$527Kavg. price
43 recorded sales
9

Noah Bailey

Keller Williams Realty Atlantic Partners (st. Aug), St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
14sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$12Mvolume (12 mo)
$511Kavg. price
97 recorded sales
10

Carol Sullivan

Lighthouse Realty Associates, St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
18sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$7.6Mvolume (12 mo)
$590Kavg. price
27 recorded sales
11

Alexia Cipollone

DJ & Lindsey Real Estate, Saint Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
12sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$14Mvolume (12 mo)
$457Kavg. price
39 recorded sales
12

Julia Almstead

EXP Realty LLC, Jacksonville, FL
No reviews yet
17sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$4.5Mvolume (12 mo)
$433Kavg. price
29 recorded sales
13

Stacey Burkins

Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty, Orange Park, FL
No reviews yet
12sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$13Mvolume (12 mo)
$727Kavg. price
21 recorded sales
14

Teresa Mercurio

Team 100 Realty, St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
36sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$260Kvolume (12 mo)
$341Kavg. price
44 recorded sales
15

Luke Newcomer

The Newcomer Group, St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
16sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$4.2Mvolume (12 mo)
$526Kavg. price
34 recorded sales
16

Michael Gagliardi

RE/MAX Signature, Port Orange, FL
No reviews yet
3sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$89Mvolume (12 mo)
$358Kavg. price
564 recorded sales
17

Donald Della Sala

DJ & Lindsey Real Esate, Palm Beach Gardens, FL
No reviews yet
6sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$20Mvolume (12 mo)
$443Kavg. price
57 recorded sales
18

Maria Tilton

Berkshire Hathaway Homeservice (oceanshore), Palm Coast, FL
No reviews yet
9sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$7.5Mvolume (12 mo)
$382Kavg. price
55 recorded sales
19

Elizabeth Kelly

One Sothebys International, Palm Coast, FL
No reviews yet
14sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$2.3Mvolume (12 mo)
$355Kavg. price
21 recorded sales
20

Chad Neumann

Chad and Sandy Real Estate Grp, Jacksonville, FL
No reviews yet
6sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$11Mvolume (12 mo)
$395Kavg. price
73 recorded sales
21

Andrew Michael

Real Broker, LLC, Orlando, FL
No reviews yet
11sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$4.5Mvolume (12 mo)
$450Kavg. price
24 recorded sales
22

Delilla Harts

Florida Homes Realty & Mortgage, Palm Coast, FL
No reviews yet
11sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$5.5Mvolume (12 mo)
$666Kavg. price
15 recorded sales
23

John Lawrence

Iheart Realty Inc., St. Augustine, FL
No reviews yet
11sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$2.8Mvolume (12 mo)
$552Kavg. price
17 recorded sales
24

Joshua Hanoud, PA

EXP Realty LLC, Jacksonville, FL
No reviews yet
5sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$12Mvolume (12 mo)
$358Kavg. price
88 recorded sales
25

Julie Sabine

Century 21 Realty Exchange, Palm Coast, FL
No reviews yet
3sales in St. Augustine (3 yrs)
$30Mvolume (12 mo)
$389Kavg. price
228 recorded sales

How this list is made

We count each agent's closed sales in St. Augustine over the past 36 months. Sales matched to sale records count fully; agent-reported sales count at 70% until matched. Recent volume, experience and a review score adjusted for review count make up the rest. Reviews can only come from a client with a completed transaction. Full details are in our ranking methodology and review verification policy.

Questions about real estate agents in St. Augustine, FL

Who are the top real estate agents in St. Augustine, FL?

As of November 2026, Agent Inc ranks Nancy Pruitt, Charlie Rogers and Karen Lindsey as the top 3 real estate agents in St. Augustine, FL. Nancy Pruitt has 197 closed sales in St. Augustine over the last three years; Charlie Rogers has 199 closed sales in St. Augustine over the last three years; Karen Lindsey has 38 closed sales in St. Augustine over the last three years. The ranking comes from Agent Inc's analysis of closed sales records and client reviews.

How does Agent Inc rank real estate agents in St. Augustine, FL?

Agents are ranked on their closed sales in St. Augustine over the past 36 months, their sales volume in the last 12 months, years licensed, and a review score that accounts for how many reviews an agent has. Reviews can only be written by a client with a completed transaction. The full method is published at https://agentinc.com/how-we-rank/.

How many homes sold in St. Augustine, FL in the last 12 months?

Agent Inc has 444 closed sales on record in St. Augustine for the last 12 months.

How many agents are on the St. Augustine, FL list, and how many of those sales did they close?

This page lists the 25 highest-ranked agents in St. Augustine, FL. Between them they closed 759 closed sales in St. Augustine over the last three years.

Which top agents in St. Augustine, FL work with the most buyers?

Among the 25 agents on this list, by buyer-side closed sales in St. Augustine over the last three years: Luke Newcomer (15), Donald Della Sala (14), Nancy Pruitt (9).

Which top agents in St. Augustine, FL sell the most homes for sellers?

Among the 25 agents on this list, by seller-side closed sales in St. Augustine over the last three years: Charlie Rogers (199), Nancy Pruitt (195), Karen Lindsey (37).

How do I check that a real estate agent in Florida is licensed?

Every Agent Inc profile shows the agent's Florida license number where it is on file, so you can look it up with the state real estate regulator. Only licensed agents and brokers are listed.

How often is the St. Augustine, FL ranking updated?

Rankings are recomputed whenever new sale records and reviews are loaded. This list was last updated in November 2026.

St Johns County

Top real estate agents in St Johns County, FL

Top agents in nearby cities