Top Real Estate Agents in McHenry, IL for 2026

These 25 agents closed 273 sales in McHenry over the last three years. This list starts from recorded local sales, recent volume and reviews from clients with a completed transaction. It is Agent Inc's editorial opinion; see our editorial policy.

Updated November 2026. Rankings are recomputed daily. How we rank

1

Jim Starwalt

Better Homes and Garden Real Estate Star Homes, Grayslake, IL
No reviews yet
23sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$98Mvolume (12 mo)
$370Kavg. price
280 recorded sales
2

Dawn Bremer

Keller Williams Success Realty, Barrington, IL
No reviews yet
26sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$24Mvolume (12 mo)
$385Kavg. price
67 recorded sales
3

Shawn Strach

Dream Real Estate, Inc., McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
34sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$6.9Mvolume (12 mo)
$328Kavg. price
68 recorded sales
4

Kim Alden

Compass, Barrington, IL
No reviews yet
14sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$104Mvolume (12 mo)
$460Kavg. price
236 recorded sales
5

Heidi Peterson

RE/MAX Plaza, McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
17sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$20Mvolume (12 mo)
$373Kavg. price
55 recorded sales
6

Lisa Jensen

Keller Williams North Shore West, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
15sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$15Mvolume (12 mo)
$340Kavg. price
46 recorded sales
7

Gregory Klemstein

RE/MAX Plaza, McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
14sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$16Mvolume (12 mo)
$344Kavg. price
138 recorded sales
8

Tyler Lewke

Keller Williams Success Realty, Crystal Lake, IL
No reviews yet
9sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$55Mvolume (12 mo)
$428Kavg. price
135 recorded sales
9

Sarah Leonard

Legacy Properties, A Sarah Leonard Company, LLC, St. Charles, IL
No reviews yet
6sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$170Mvolume (12 mo)
$437Kavg. price
401 recorded sales
10

Kevin Dombrowski

HomeSmart Connect LLC, McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
10sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$22Mvolume (12 mo)
$548Kavg. price
41 recorded sales
11

Brandy Schuldt

Keller Williams North Shore West, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
10sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$9.6Mvolume (12 mo)
$383Kavg. price
25 recorded sales
12

Richard Toepper

Keller Williams Success Realty, Crystal Lake, IL
No reviews yet
8sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$18Mvolume (12 mo)
$406Kavg. price
45 recorded sales
13

Jamie Decker

EXP Realty, Schaumburg, IL
No reviews yet
9sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$12Mvolume (12 mo)
$452Kavg. price
28 recorded sales
14

Maureen Forgette

Century 21 Integra, McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
8sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$12Mvolume (12 mo)
$323Kavg. price
38 recorded sales
15

Ashley Arzer

Redfin Corporation, Chicago, IL
No reviews yet
7sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$19Mvolume (12 mo)
$432Kavg. price
44 recorded sales
16

Kelly Vance

Century 21 Integra, McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
9sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$5.8Mvolume (12 mo)
$295Kavg. price
22 recorded sales
17

Richard O'Connor

Realty Executives Cornerstone, Crystal Lake, IL
No reviews yet
7sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$12Mvolume (12 mo)
$399Kavg. price
31 recorded sales
18

Jamie Hering

Coldwell Banker Realty, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
4sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$55Mvolume (12 mo)
$407Kavg. price
136 recorded sales
19

Beth Repta

LPT Realty, Barrington, IL
No reviews yet
5sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$22Mvolume (12 mo)
$462Kavg. price
51 recorded sales
20

Dennis Drake

Century 21 Integra, McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
8sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$4.1Mvolume (12 mo)
$312Kavg. price
16 recorded sales
21

Susan Miller

Dream Real Estate, Inc., McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
7sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$4.5Mvolume (12 mo)
$277Kavg. price
17 recorded sales
22

Jay Nalley

Nalley Realty, McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
8sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$2.4Mvolume (12 mo)
$257Kavg. price
11 recorded sales
23

Christopher Lobrillo

Grandview Realty, LLC, Geneva, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$44Mvolume (12 mo)
$306Kavg. price
153 recorded sales
24

Dorene Swanson

Glacier Realty, Inc., Ringwood, IL
No reviews yet
7sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$3.2Mvolume (12 mo)
$277Kavg. price
13 recorded sales
25

Shannon Bremner

Keller Williams Success Realty, Barrington, IL
No reviews yet
5sales in McHenry (3 yrs)
$12Mvolume (12 mo)
$443Kavg. price
28 recorded sales

How this list is made

We count each agent's closed sales in McHenry over the past 36 months. Sales matched to sale records count fully; agent-reported sales count at 70% until matched. Recent volume, experience and a review score adjusted for review count make up the rest. Reviews can only come from a client with a completed transaction. Full details are in our ranking methodology and review verification policy.

Top agents in nearby cities