Top Real Estate Agents in Island Lake, IL for 2026

These 25 agents closed 60 sales in Island Lake over the last three years. This list starts from recorded local sales, recent volume and reviews from clients with a completed transaction. It is Agent Inc's editorial opinion; see our editorial policy.

Updated November 2026. Rankings are recomputed daily. How we rank

1

Jim Starwalt

Better Homes and Garden Real Estate Star Homes, Grayslake, IL
No reviews yet
4sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$98Mvolume (12 mo)
$370Kavg. price
280 recorded sales
2

Kim Alden

Compass, Barrington, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$104Mvolume (12 mo)
$460Kavg. price
236 recorded sales
3

Sean Ryan

Ryan and Company REALTORS, Inc, Wauconda, IL
No reviews yet
5sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$2.9Mvolume (12 mo)
$302Kavg. price
11 recorded sales
4

Ryan Cherney

Circle One Realty, Yorkville, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$114Mvolume (12 mo)
$418Kavg. price
289 recorded sales
5

Patricia Palzet-Taylor

RE/MAX Plaza, Wauconda, IL
No reviews yet
4sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$3.6Mvolume (12 mo)
$441Kavg. price
9 recorded sales
6

Tami Hamilton

@properties Christie's International Real Estate, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$13Mvolume (12 mo)
$582Kavg. price
22 recorded sales
7

Amber Cawley

HomeSmart Connect LLC, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$10Mvolume (12 mo)
$417Kavg. price
29 recorded sales
8

Kevin Kalbach

Realty Executives Cornerstone, Crystal Lake, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$8.2Mvolume (12 mo)
$389Kavg. price
21 recorded sales
9

Isabel Galan

@properties Christie's International Real Estate, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$10Mvolume (12 mo)
$527Kavg. price
21 recorded sales
10

Tyler Lewke

Keller Williams Success Realty, Crystal Lake, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$55Mvolume (12 mo)
$428Kavg. price
135 recorded sales
11

Ty Barton

RE/MAX Suburban, Lake Zurich, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$4.2Mvolume (12 mo)
$422Kavg. price
10 recorded sales
12

Erin Dreiling

Baird & Warner, Lake Zurich, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$4.3Mvolume (12 mo)
$427Kavg. price
10 recorded sales
13

Arturo Flores

EXP Realty, Woodstock, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$17Mvolume (12 mo)
$304Kavg. price
59 recorded sales
14

Conor McDowell

@properties Christie's International Real Estate, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
3sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$1.5Mvolume (12 mo)
$293Kavg. price
14 recorded sales
15

Sarah Leonard

Legacy Properties, A Sarah Leonard Company, LLC, St. Charles, IL
No reviews yet
1sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$170Mvolume (12 mo)
$437Kavg. price
401 recorded sales
16

Michelle Nunez

Baird & Warner, Lake Zurich, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$12Mvolume (12 mo)
$443Kavg. price
29 recorded sales
17

Grant Fetter

Compass, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$9.3Mvolume (12 mo)
$423Kavg. price
22 recorded sales
18

Stephanie Seplowin

Coldwell Banker Realty, Long Grove, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$8.8Mvolume (12 mo)
$387Kavg. price
25 recorded sales
19

Cyndy Hass

@properties Christie's International Real Estate, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$12Mvolume (12 mo)
$581Kavg. price
20 recorded sales
20

Michael Scanlon

EXP Realty, Chicago, IL
No reviews yet
1sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$88Mvolume (12 mo)
$297Kavg. price
302 recorded sales
21

Pamela Coester-Oswald

RE/MAX Plaza, McHenry, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$5.5Mvolume (12 mo)
$366Kavg. price
15 recorded sales
22

Lisa Wolf

Keller Williams North Shore West, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
1sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$75Mvolume (12 mo)
$494Kavg. price
157 recorded sales
23

Jamie Hering

Coldwell Banker Realty, Libertyville, IL
No reviews yet
1sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$55Mvolume (12 mo)
$407Kavg. price
136 recorded sales
24

Katie Holmes

Keller Williams Success Realty, Barrington, IL
No reviews yet
2sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$3.4Mvolume (12 mo)
$375Kavg. price
9 recorded sales
25

Mike Berg

Berg Properties, Oak Park, IL
No reviews yet
1sales in Island Lake (3 yrs)
$53Mvolume (12 mo)
$439Kavg. price
125 recorded sales

How this list is made

We count each agent's closed sales in Island Lake over the past 36 months. Sales matched to sale records count fully; agent-reported sales count at 70% until matched. Recent volume, experience and a review score adjusted for review count make up the rest. Reviews can only come from a client with a completed transaction. Full details are in our ranking methodology and review verification policy.

Top agents in nearby cities