# Top Real Estate Agents in Pinehurst, NC for 2026

Source: Agent Inc, https://agentinc.com/top-real-estate-agents/pinehurst-nc/
Updated: November 2026

Pinehurst had 73 closed sales on record in the last 12 months. The 25 agents ranked here closed 138 of the sales in Pinehurst over the last three years. Rankings and featured placements come from Agent Inc's own analysis of sales records, licensing records and client reviews.

## Ranked agents

1. [Meese Property Group](https://agentinc.com/agents/meese-property-group-1032409/), Meese Property Group, Southern Pines, NC. 26 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $15M total volume (12 months).
2. [Janet Rogers](https://agentinc.com/agents/janet-rogers-1029740/), D. R. Horton, Inc, Greenville, NC. 6 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $185M total volume (12 months).
3. [Scott Lincicome](https://agentinc.com/agents/scott-lincicome-1023787/), Bh&g Real Estate - Lifestyle Property Partners, Pinehurst, NC. 13 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $12M total volume (12 months).
4. [Angela Thompson](https://agentinc.com/agents/angela-thompson-1021921/), Keller Williams Realty (pinehurst), Southern Pines, NC. 8 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $11M total volume (12 months).
5. [Jennifer Ritchie](https://agentinc.com/agents/jennifer-ritchie-1017728/), Everything Pines Partners Llc, Southern Pines, NC. 4 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $30M total volume (12 months).
6. [Jennifer Nguyen](https://agentinc.com/agents/jennifer-nguyen-1017941/), Keller Williams Realty (pinehurst), Southern Pines, NC. 8 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $6.1M total volume (12 months).
7. [Terry Nanney](https://agentinc.com/agents/terry-nanney-1022971/), EXP Realty LLC, Fayetteville, NC. 6 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $4.2M total volume (12 months).
8. [Welcome Home Team Powered By Keller Williams Realty](https://agentinc.com/agents/welcome-home-team-powered-by-keller-williams-realty-1024557/), Keller Williams Realty (fayetteville), Fayetteville, NC. 2 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $54M total volume (12 months).
9. [Lisa Murphy](https://agentinc.com/agents/lisa-murphy-1019482/), Everything Pines Partners Llc, Southern Pines, NC. 4 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $10M total volume (12 months).
10. [Ashley Schaus](https://agentinc.com/agents/ashley-schaus-1025065/), Keller Williams Realty (pinehurst), Southern Pines, NC. 4 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $6.1M total volume (12 months).
11. [Donell Keith](https://agentinc.com/agents/donell-keith-1018187/), Keller Williams Realty (pinehurst), Southern Pines, NC. 5 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $3.6M total volume (12 months).
12. [Allison Sanders](https://agentinc.com/agents/allison-sanders-1031296/), Choice Residential Real Estate, Raleigh, NC. 4 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $6.8M total volume (12 months).
13. [Donna Ryals](https://agentinc.com/agents/donna-ryals-1023333/), Bhhs Pinehurst Realty Group, Pinehurst, NC. 5 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $3.2M total volume (12 months).
14. [Cherry Amanatidis](https://agentinc.com/agents/cherry-amanatidis-1025128/), Premier Real Estate Of The Sandhills Llc, Southern Pines, NC. 5 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $3.9M total volume (12 months).
15. [Janice Nesbitt](https://agentinc.com/agents/janice-nesbitt-1018742/), Pulte Home Company, LLC, Cary, NC. 17 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years).
16. [Peter Mace](https://agentinc.com/agents/peter-mace-1020926/), Carolina Property Sales, Southern Pines, NC. 2 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $23M total volume (12 months).
17. [Bobby Taboada](https://agentinc.com/agents/bobby-taboada-1022762/), Coldwell Banker HPW, Raleigh, NC. 3 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $3.7M total volume (12 months).
18. [Rhonda Kosor](https://agentinc.com/agents/rhonda-kosor-1023563/), Mark Spain Real Estate, Raleigh, NC. 2 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $9.9M total volume (12 months).
19. [Linnette Reyes](https://agentinc.com/agents/linnette-reyes-1022322/), Pineland Property Group, Llc., Southern Pines, NC. 2 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $9.1M total volume (12 months).
20. [Anthony Smith](https://agentinc.com/agents/anthony-smith-1027062/), Moultrie And McCloskey Properties, Cameron, NC. 3 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $2.1M total volume (12 months).
21. [Charlotte Hagan](https://agentinc.com/agents/charlotte-hagan-1017006/), Coldwell Banker Advantage #3-Southern Pines, Southern Pines, NC. 3 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $2.7M total volume (12 months).
22. [Grullon Team Powered By Coldwell Banker Advantage](https://agentinc.com/agents/grullon-team-powered-by-coldwell-banker-advantage-1018471/), Coldwell Banker Advantage - Fayetteville, Fayetteville, NC. 1 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $24M total volume (12 months).
23. [Dark Horse Group Powered By Lpt Realty](https://agentinc.com/agents/dark-horse-group-powered-by-lpt-realty-1027344/), LPT Realty, LLC, Fayetteville, NC. 1 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $21M total volume (12 months).
24. [Kristi Snyder](https://agentinc.com/agents/kristi-snyder-1019978/), Everything Pines Partners Llc, Southern Pines, NC. 2 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $7.3M total volume (12 months).
25. [Nicole McKenna](https://agentinc.com/agents/nicole-mckenna-1020308/), Soldiers First Real Estate Llc., Fayetteville, NC. 2 closed sales in Pinehurst (3 years); $3.6M total volume (12 months).

## Questions and answers

### Who are the top real estate agents in Pinehurst, NC?
As of November 2026, Agent Inc ranks Meese Property Group, Janet Rogers and Scott Lincicome as the top 3 real estate agents in Pinehurst, NC. Meese Property Group has 26 closed sales in Pinehurst over the last three years; Janet Rogers has 6 closed sales in Pinehurst over the last three years; Scott Lincicome has 13 closed sales in Pinehurst over the last three years. The ranking comes from Agent Inc's analysis of closed sales records and client reviews.

### How does Agent Inc rank real estate agents in Pinehurst, NC?
Agents are ranked on their closed sales in Pinehurst over the past 36 months, their sales volume in the last 12 months, years licensed, and a review score that accounts for how many reviews an agent has. Reviews can only be written by a client with a completed transaction. The full method is published at https://agentinc.com/how-we-rank/.

### How many homes sold in Pinehurst, NC in the last 12 months?
Agent Inc has 73 closed sales on record in Pinehurst for the last 12 months.

### How many agents are on the Pinehurst, NC list, and how many of those sales did they close?
This page lists the 25 highest-ranked agents in Pinehurst, NC. Between them they closed 138 closed sales in Pinehurst over the last three years.

### Which top agents in Pinehurst, NC work with the most buyers?
Among the 25 agents on this list, by buyer-side closed sales in Pinehurst over the last three years: Allison Sanders (3), Scott Lincicome (2), Jennifer Nguyen (1).

### Which top agents in Pinehurst, NC sell the most homes for sellers?
Among the 25 agents on this list, by seller-side closed sales in Pinehurst over the last three years: Meese Property Group (26), Janice Nesbitt (17), Scott Lincicome (11).

### How do I check that a real estate agent in North Carolina is licensed?
Every Agent Inc profile shows the agent's North Carolina license number where it is on file, so you can look it up with the state real estate regulator. Only licensed agents and brokers are listed.

### How often is the Pinehurst, NC ranking updated?
Rankings are recomputed whenever new sale records and reviews are loaded. This list was last updated in November 2026.

## How this list is made

Closed sales in Pinehurst over the past 36 months count most. Recent volume, experience and a review score adjusted for review count make up the rest. Method: https://agentinc.com/how-we-rank/
